Montello Care Center
Montello Care Center
2.6 (19 reviews)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 50 Licensed Beds
251 Forest Lane, Montello, WI
CMS Medicare Ratings
Overall
Inspection
Staffing
Quality
View details →
Call
Claimed

Montello Care Center

Skilled Nursing Facility • 50 Licensed Beds
251 Forest Lane,
Montello, WI
CMS Medicare Ratings
Overall
Inspection
Staffing
Quality
View details →
About

Montello Care Center – Medicare Certified Since 2000

Montello Care Center is a Medicare and Medicaid certified skilled nursing facility located in Montello, Wisconsin. This facility has been serving the community for 26 years. A Medicare-certified skilled nursing facility provides 24-hour nursing care, rehabilitation services, and assistance with activities of daily living for patients who need skilled nursing or rehabilitation services on a daily basis.

This facility has 50 certified beds with a current occupancy rate of 61% (averaging 30 residents per day), which is below average. Skilled nursing facilities provide 24-hour nursing care for patients who need rehabilitation services after a hospital stay or ongoing care for chronic conditions. Services include skilled nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, and assistance with daily activities.

Staffing Levels: Based on CMS payroll data, this facility provides approximately 4.86 hours of total nursing care per resident per day (3.42 hours from CNAs, 0.69 hours from LPNs, 0.75 hours from RNs). Physical therapy staffing is 0.05 hours per resident per day. This represents above-average staffing compared to national benchmarks.

Medicare Quality Ratings: According to CMS, Montello Care Center has an overall quality rating of 1 out of 5 stars, which is much below average compared to other nursing homes nationwide. Individual category ratings are: health inspection: 1 stars, staffing: 3 stars, quality measures: 4 stars.

Medicare Coverage: Medicare covers skilled nursing facility care for up to 100 days following a qualifying hospital stay of at least 3 days. Days 1-20 are fully covered by Medicare, days 21-100 require a daily coinsurance payment. Many residents also use Medicaid, private insurance, or pay privately for long-term stays.

Questions to Ask: When visiting a nursing home, ask about: staff-to-resident ratios and RN coverage around the clock, how they handle medical emergencies, activities and therapy programs, how they communicate with families, their approach to falls prevention, and policies for managing resident complaints.

Visit Medicare Care Compare to view detailed ratings, inspection reports, staffing data, and compare this facility with others in the area.

Quality ratings and facility data are updated periodically by CMS. We recommend verifying current information at Medicare Care Compare.

Show Phone

Local Comparison Snapshot

How Montello Care Center compares to 134 facilities in Rural WI

Click a measure name to jump to details • Hover over for definitions

Measure
This Facility
Area Avg
Comparison
Overall Rating
Medicare 5-star rating
1
3.3
Quality Measures
Clinical outcomes & safety
4
3.2
Health Inspections
State survey results
1
3
Staffing
Nurse-to-resident ratio
3
3.7
Staffing Hours (per resident/day)
RN Hours
Registered nurses
0.75 hrs
0.96 hrs
LPN/LVN Hours
Licensed practical nurses
0.69 hrs
0.57 hrs
CNA Hours
Certified nursing assistants
3.42 hrs
2.57 hrs
Total Nursing Hours
CNA + LPN + RN combined
4.86 hrs
4.09 hrs
Agency/Contractor Usage
Lower agency use often indicates more stable, consistent care
RN Agency Use
% of RN hours from contractors
18.1 %
6.3 %
LPN/LVN Agency Use
% of LPN hours from contractors
28.7 %
16.2 %
CNA Agency Use
% of CNA hours from contractors
27.2 %
10.8 %
Staff Stability & Occupancy
Staff Turnover
Annual nursing staff turnover
64 %
44 %
Occupancy Rate
Percentage of beds filled
61 %
73 %
Financial Estimate
Based on CMS Cost Report data (for reference only)
Est. Daily Rate
Average cost per day
$409
$380
Estimate Only: This figure is calculated from cost reports and is for informational purposes only. Actual rates vary significantly. See details or contact the facility.
Better than Area
Near Average
Below Area Average

Data from CMS Medicare Compare and Payroll-Based Journal. Area averages based on 134 facilities in Rural WI.
Ratings and staffing data typically reflect the most recent quarterly reporting period available.

View Other Options Near You

Featured

Maplewood of Sauk Prairie

245 SYCAMORE ST
Sauk City, WI 53583 (41 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 120 beds
★★★★★ 4.2 (29 reviews)
Show Phone
View Listing
Claimed

Markesan Resident Home

1130 N MARGARET
Markesan, WI 53946 (17 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 50 beds
★★★★★ 4.0 (8 reviews)
Show Phone
View Listing
Claimed

Columbia Health Care Center

323 W MONROE ST PO BOX 895
Wyocena, WI 53969 (21 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 95 beds
★★★★★ 4.1 (62 reviews)
Show Phone
View Listing

Juliette Manor

482 OAK STREET
Berlin, WI 54923 (23 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 37 beds
Show Phone
View Listing
Claimed

Randolph Health Services

502 S HIGH ST
Randolph, WI 53956 (24 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 84 beds
★★★★★ 4.2 (6 reviews)
Show Phone
View Listing

Whispering Pines Nursing and Rehab, LLC

50 WOLVERTON AVE
Ripon, WI 54971 (24 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 50 beds
Show Phone
View Listing
Claimed

Wisconsin Dells Health Services

300 RACE ST
Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965 (25 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 90 beds
★★★★★ 3.6 (15 reviews)
Show Phone
View Listing

Villa Pines Living Center

201 PARK ST, PO BOX 130
Friendship, WI 53934 (28 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 50 beds
Show Phone
View Listing

Ssm Health St Clare Meadows Care Ctr

1414 JEFFERSON ST
Baraboo, WI 53913 (30 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 102 beds
Show Phone
View Listing

Christian Home and Rehab Ctr

331 BLY ST
Waupun, WI 53963 (31 miles away)
Skilled Nursing Facility • 50 beds
Show Phone
View Listing

Medicare Star Ratings

Official CMS ratings based on health inspections, staffing, and quality measures

Data as of December 2025

What do Medicare star ratings measure?
Medicare rates nursing homes on a 1-5 star scale based on three key areas: health inspection results, staffing levels, and quality measures like falls and infections.
How often are ratings updated?
CMS updates nursing home ratings monthly. Ratings can change based on new inspection results, staffing data from payroll records, and clinical quality outcomes.
Overall Rating
1/5
Quality Measures
4/5
Health Inspections
1/5
Staffing
3/5

Star Ratings History

Quarterly performance from 2013-2026

View on Medicare.gov
Overall
Health Inspections
Quality
Staffing
Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

How Does This Facility Compare?

Compared to 134 other nursing homes in Rural WI

Why compare to local facilities?
Local comparisons account for regional staffing markets and demographics. A facility performing above local averages often indicates strong management and quality care relative to area standards.
Montello Care Center
Rural WI Average

Based on CMS Medicare star ratings. Higher ratings indicate better performance.

Staffing Hours per Resident Day

Montello Care Center
Rural WI Average

Staffing data from CMS Payroll-Based Journal. Higher hours generally indicate more direct care time.

Staff Turnover Rate

Montello Care Center
Rural WI Average

Lower turnover rates generally indicate a more stable workforce and better continuity of care.

Agency/Contract Staff Usage

Montello Care Center
Rural WI Average

Lower agency usage often indicates better staff retention. High agency rates (>30%) may suggest staffing challenges.

Agency Staff Trends

Historical agency/contract staff usage by role

What does agency usage indicate?
Agency/contract staff fill temporary staffing gaps. Lower percentages typically indicate a stable, permanent workforce. Facilities with consistently high agency usage (>30%) may face staff retention challenges, though temporary spikes can occur during seasonal illness or transitions.
CNA
LPN
RN

Data from CMS Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ). Agency % = contractor hours / total hours.

Direct Care Staffing

Average minutes of direct nursing care per resident per day

Data as of December 2025

Understanding staffing levels: Higher staffing is associated with better quality outcomes. Research suggests around 4.1 hours of total nursing care per resident per day as a quality benchmark. Compare this facility's staffing to local averages to assess relative care levels.
205
minutes/day
CNAs
Certified Nursing Assistants
41
minutes/day
LPNs
Licensed Practical Nurses
45
minutes/day
RNs
Registered Nurses
3
minutes/day
PTs
Physical Therapists

Staffing Trends

Direct care minutes per resident per day

CNAs
LPNs
RNs
PTs
Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

Occupancy Rate History

Average daily residents as a percentage of certified beds

Understanding occupancy: Higher occupancy can indicate strong community reputation and demand. Very low occupancy may affect financial stability, while extremely high occupancy could mean limited bed availability.
Montello Care Center
Rural WI Average (72.6%)

Data from CMS Provider Info files. Occupancy = Average Residents per Day / Certified Beds.

Staff Turnover History

Annual percentage of nursing staff who left the facility

Data as of December 2025

Understanding turnover: Lower turnover rates generally indicate a more stable workforce and better continuity of care. High turnover can affect care quality and resident relationships. The national average for nursing homes is around 50-60%.
All Nursing Staff
Registered Nurses (RN)
Area Average

Data from CMS Payroll-Based Journal. Turnover = staff who left during the year / total staff.

Average Daily Rate

Average daily charge for care at this facility

Based on CMS Cost Report data (inpatient revenue ÷ total patient days)

FY 2023 Daily Rate
$409
per resident per day
Compared to 133 facilities in your area
Above local median ($380)
Daily Rate Trend (2018-2023)
Contact Facility for Actual Rates
This figure is an average calculated from cost reports and is for informational purposes only. Actual rates vary significantly based on level of care needed, room type, payer source (Medicare, Medicaid, private pay), and other factors. Please contact the facility directly for current pricing and availability.
How This Is Calculated
This average daily rate is calculated from CMS Cost Reports by dividing total inpatient revenue by total patient days. It represents an average across all payers and care levels. Higher rates may indicate more intensive care, specialized services, or regional cost factors.

Data Source: Financial data from CMS Skilled Nursing Facility Cost Reports. Data typically lags 1-2 years. This information is for educational purposes only and should not be the sole basis for financial or care decisions. CareListings does not guarantee accuracy.

Financial Health

Comprehensive financial indicators from CMS Cost Reports

Data from fiscal year 2023 (most recent available - cost report data lags ~2 years)

Nonprofit Facility

Financial Summary

Metric This Facility Local Median Comparison
Operating Margin
Profitability ratio
-9% -2% Below
Net Income
Annual profit or loss
$-361,780 $162,552 Below
Staff Cost per Resident
Daily salary expense per resident
$255/day $163/day Higher
Occupancy Rate
Bed utilization percentage
61% 72% Lower
Est. Daily Rate
Average revenue per patient day
$409/day $380/day Higher
Total Beds
Licensed bed capacity
50 50 Smaller

Local comparisons based on 133 skilled nursing facilities in the Wisconsin (Rural) metro area

Revenue & Expenses

Net Patient Revenue
After adjustments & allowances
$4,163,198
Operating Expenses
Total operating costs
$4,545,380
Total Salaries
Staff compensation
$2,537,314
Contract Labor
Agency & temp staff
$29,064

Payer Mix

Medicare
7%
Medicaid
71%
Private Pay & Other
21%

Operating Margin Trend (2018-2023)

Understanding Financial Health
Operating Margin: Percentage of revenue remaining after operating costs. Positive = profitable operations.
Staff Investment: Higher spending per resident often correlates with better care quality.
Payer Mix: Shows revenue sources. Higher Medicare % typically means more post-acute/rehab care; higher Medicaid % indicates more long-term care residents.
Nonprofit/Government: May operate with lower margins while still providing quality care due to community mission.

Data Source: All financial data on this page comes from CMS Skilled Nursing Facility Cost Reports submitted by the facility to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. This information is provided for educational purposes only and should not be the sole basis for any financial or care decisions. Cost report data typically lags 1-2 years. CareListings does not guarantee the accuracy of this data.

Who Stays Here

Breakdown of residents by payment type

Based on fiscal year 2023 cost report data

Total Days
9,938
Medicare
Short-term skilled nursing
7%
Medicaid
Long-term care residents
71%
Private Pay / Other
Self-pay, insurance, VA
21%
Higher Medicare %
Indicates more short-term rehabilitation residents. Medicare typically covers up to 100 days of skilled nursing care after a hospital stay.
Higher Medicaid %
Indicates more long-term care residents. Medicaid covers nursing home care for those who qualify financially.

Average Length of Stay

How long residents typically stay at this facility

Based on fiscal year 2023 cost report data

Overall Average
108.02
days
Medicare Stays
27.73
days
Medicaid Stays
244.62
days
Total Admissions
108
Total Discharges
92
Medicare (Short-Term)
Medicare covers skilled nursing for rehabilitation after a hospital stay. Typical stays are 20-30 days for recovery from surgery, stroke, or illness.
Medicaid (Long-Term)
Medicaid covers long-term nursing home care for those who qualify. Many residents stay months or years, receiving ongoing daily care and support.

Services

Comprehensive skilled nursing services, rehabilitation programs, and medical care in MONTELLO

Join Our Caring Team

We're always looking for compassionate individuals who are dedicated to providing exceptional care for our residents. Explore career opportunities at Montello Care Center.

Current Job Openings

Montello Care Center
MONTELLO, WI
Full Time
View Job
Montello Care Center
MONTELLO, WI
Full Time
View Job

Reviews

2.6 (19 reviews)
Powered by Google Logo
melanie bradica's profile photo
melanie bradica 9 months ago

I visited my grandfather while recovering from surgery. Nursing and care staff were difficult to find. Very pungent odor of urine everywhere. His room had several washcloths covered in urine and feces directly on the floor. Visible dirt and debris underneath beds, indicated lack of a good environmental/ cleaning program and best practices for care staffing. I encourage anyone to look up their government inspection history to see repeat findings and evidence of failure to report acts of negligent care and implement an infection prevention and control program. There are many more concerning violations in relation to food and safety controls and failure to provide pressure ulcer care. All recent from 2023-2024. Yes, all violations were fixed according to the website, however, given multiple findings were repeated from year to year, I have significant doubt that their corrections implemented have remained effective. Negative 10 out of 10 , do not recommend.

Doreen Gondek's profile photo
Doreen Gondek a year ago

AI was in the care center for rehab. Everyone was so friendly, kind & respectful. Always wearing a smile & giving hugs . They genuinely care about all the clients. They are efficient and work very hard. Physical therapy was amazing! Allen is very knowledgeable and helpful for me and my needs . One of the reasons my stay was short , &recovery was speedy! I had a very positive experience during my stay. I'll be going there to visit with the residents. No complaints. I'm leaving on a positive note. The food was awesome!

Tracy Steffen's profile photo
Tracy Steffen a year ago

Hi my Father came to your facility for Rehab after a fall. The staff was wonderful to my father. Alan from Rehab was excellent I can't say enough about him. The Nurses were also very kind and very interactive with my father and us as a family. The social worker was excellent also. Thank you to all of your staff that made my father stay wonderful. I appreciate it. Tracy Steffen

nila Vunuche's profile photo
nila Vunuche 10 months ago

A truly appalling nursing home would be characterized by a pervasive, unpleasant odor, likely from poor hygiene practices, with visibly soiled common areas and resident rooms, indicating inadequate cleaning routines; neglected residents with unkempt clothing and unbathed bodies due to understaffing; malfunctioning medical equipment; a lack of basic comforts like clean bedding and proper temperature control; and a general atmosphere of disarray and neglect, where residents appear uncared for and staff seem indifferent to their basic needs, creating a deeply disturbing and unsafe environment for the elderly residents. Don't send loved ones here

Sam B's profile photo
Sam B a year ago

I had totally knee replacement in Dec if last year. I came here not knowing what to expect as my previous PT experiences were horrid. This has been a WONDERFUL experience for me. My therapist, Allan, was very patient and explained why each exercise was needed to regain full motion/strength. My sessions were productive and my surgeon was thrilled w/my early progress and stated my therapist was to thank. So, if you want good experienced PT, then I highly recommend Allan at the Montello Care Center. You won't regret it.

View All 19 Google Reviews

Explore Skilled Nursing Facilities Near Montello

Discover skilled nursing facilities in nearby communities

Harrisville

7.2 mi away

Packwaukee

7.3 mi away

Endeavor

9.3 mi away

Marquette

9.8 mi away

Princeton

10.1 mi away

Westfield

10.6 mi away

Dalton

11.3 mi away

Kingston

11.8 mi away

Oxford

12.2 mi away

Neshkoro

12.8 mi away

Briggsville

16.6 mi away

Markesan

17.4 mi away

Pardeeville

18.1 mi away

Portage

18.3 mi away

Green Lake

18.3 mi away

Find Additional Care Services in Montello

Explore additional care options and services available in your area